Mortgage Fraud in California - Penal Code 532f
California Penal Code Section 532f is a crucial statute that addresses mortgage fraud, a severe and intricate white-collar crime that is rigorously prosecuted in the state. It targets illicit activities in real estate transactions and imposes stringent penalties on individuals found guilty of deceiving lenders, fabricating loan documents, or participating in fraudulent schemes.
Real estate, mortgage, and finance professionals, as well as individual borrowers, should understand the scope and potential consequences of the law. It is crucial to be well-versed in California Penal Code 532f, which criminalizes the intentional misrepresentation, omission, or deception of material facts to obtain a mortgage loan.
Common violations include falsifying income or employment data on applications, using straw buyers to hide the true borrower's identity, inflating property values through manipulated appraisals, and misrepresenting occupancy intentions.
This law has a wide-ranging impact, encompassing a diverse group of individuals, including loan applicants, mortgage brokers, underwriters, real estate agents, and appraisers. Due to its extensive reach, even minor inaccuracies in paperwork can lead to criminal charges. California courts handle a broad spectrum of mortgage fraud cases. The most common types include income:
- Misrepresentation (inflating earnings to qualify for larger loans),
- Property value manipulation (overstating property values through biased appraisals), and
- Straw buyer schemes (using third parties to secure loans under false pretenses).
Professional Consequences
California Financial Code 4973 directly incorporates Penal Code 532f, making mortgage originators involved in fraud criminally liable. This connection has serious professional repercussions.
Violations can result in disciplinary actions, such as permanent license revocation, based on the same conduct that leads to criminal charges. Those facing charges under PC 532f should also consider the potential impact on their career, especially if they are prosecuted as career criminals under California Penal Code 999e.
Section 7480 of the Government Code allows courts to issue orders under PC 532f(c), requiring banks and financial institutions to disclose account and transaction details during investigations.
Defense attorneys must carefully review these procedures to ensure that law enforcement respects financial privacy laws and regulations. A single mistake could result in the suppression of evidence obtained unlawfully, which could be crucial for achieving a favorable result.
Straw Buyer Schemes
In California criminal law, a "straw buyer" refers to an individual who makes purchases on behalf of another person. This setup aims to conceal the true buyer's identity, often because they are unable to purchase legally themselves.
While acting as a straw buyer is not illegal in itself, it becomes a crime when deception is involved to facilitate the transaction, especially with regulated items like firearms or in financial transactions such as real estate.
Engaging in a straw purchase under fraudulent conditions can result in severe legal penalties, depending on the specifics of the transaction and the applicable laws. These penalties may include hefty fines, orders to pay restitution to victims, and long prison terms.
Several California statutes address the fraudulent activities associated with straw buying. These offenses often involve misrepresentation and deceit, which form the basis for criminal charges. Below are some of the most common crimes where straw buyers play a key role.
Mortgage Fraud Offense
Mortgage fraud happens when individuals intentionally provide false information or misrepresent facts during the mortgage process to obtain a loan under false pretenses. Straw buyers are commonly exploited in these schemes; for example, someone with poor credit or disqualifying factors may recruit a straw buyer-someone with better financial credentials submit a loan application in their name.
PC 532f specifies several illegal acts, such as knowingly preparing, submitting, or presenting false documents related to a mortgage, as well as falsely claiming material facts to support a loan application. This law applies to buyers, sellers, brokers, and straw buyers.
Grand Theft Offense
Grand theft, as defined under Penal Code 487 PC, is a broad offense that often involves the actions of a straw buyer.
It occurs when someone takes property worth over $950 through false pretenses, tricks, or embezzlement. In a typical straw buyer case, the person falsely claims to be the actual purchaser of a vehicle or the intended resident of a property, thereby convincing a seller or lender to hand over the property or money.
Filing a False Document
Filing a forged document under Penal Code 115 PC criminalizes intentionally submitting, registering, or recording a false or forged document with a public office in California.
Straw buyer schemes often involve creating and submitting falsified documents. For example, a straw buyer in a real estate deal might sign a deed of trust or loan application with false details about income, employment, or plans to occupy the property. When these fraudulent documents are filed with the county recorder's office, it constitutes a violation of PC 115.
Foreclosure Fraud
Foreclosure fraud is a deceptive practice that targets homeowners facing financial difficulties, often exploiting their vulnerability to seize their property and equity. According to California Civil Code 2945.4, it is illegal for foreclosure consultants to engage in deceptive or fraudulent activities.
This law specifically bans practices such as misrepresenting the details of a foreclosure rescue plan, charging unfairly high fees, or failing to provide promised services. Violating this law can result in severe consequences, including criminal charges, fines, and imprisonment.
Straw buyers frequently play a key role in foreclosure fraud schemes. Typically, a foreclosure advisor persuades a distressed homeowner to transfer their property deed to a straw buyer, claiming it's a temporary measure.
The advisor may assure the homeowner that they can stay in the home as a tenant and buy it back later. Meanwhile, the straw buyer, acting on behalf of the advisor, refinances the home, extracts its equity, and allows it to go into foreclosure. As a result, the original homeowner is evicted, loses their property, and often has no legal options.
Mortgage Fraud Penalties
Mortgage fraud under PC 532f is generally prosecuted as a felony, though the specific charges and penalties depend on the scope and amount of the fraud. Possible penalties include:
- Two to five years in county jail,
- Fines often in excess of $10,000,
- Mandatory restitution to victims,
- Asset forfeiture and civil penalties.
Individuals involved in mortgage fraud may also face the loss of their license, significant damage to their professional reputation, and civil lawsuits from lenders or other parties involved. These personal and financial risks should be a strong deterrent against engaging in fraudulent activities.
Mortgage Fraud Defenses
Our California criminal defense attorneys employ various legal strategies to assist clients in defending against charges related to illegal straw purchases.
We might argue there was no intent to defraud, as typically, someone is guilty of a straw-buying scheme only if they deliberately aim to deceive.
Police must have a valid search warrant to search or seize items lawfully; without it, they need a legal justification for acting without one.
Consequently, the defendant can consistently claim that the search or seizure was conducted unlawfully and that the officers lacked a valid reason for not obtaining a warrant.
Entrapment is a strong defense when arrests happen during undercover operations, asserting that police persuaded or enticed the accused to commit the crime. For more information, contact the Hedding Law Firm, located in Los Angeles, CA.
Related Content:
